How political exploitation of Paris’ protests is killing the high schoolers’ movement

Written by Ethan Taieb

Walking among protesters in Paris on October 17th, reading signs about the cost of living and police violence, I was surprised by how little violence I witnessed. I went home with my pictures taken, and the goggles I had brought to protect myself from tear gas still unused. But that peacefulness is not what anyone will remember from that day. After the official protests dispersed, waves of violence broke out across the country and continued into Sunday. A historic city hall was set ablaze and largely destroyed, an estimated 2,500 shops were looted or vandalised, teenagers and other protesters were wounded, and 997 police officers and gendarmes injured. The country woke up on Sunday with the feeling that civil war was upon it.The events of that weekend drew comments from politicians and commentators around the world, each pursuing their own agenda. The right-wing used them as a justification for anti-immigration policy; the left praised the movement as an example to be followed. In France, radical parties on both sides of the political landscape exploited the protests as campaign fodder. Marine Le Pen (candidate of the far-right Rassemblement National) only has to say the words “order”, “security” and “delinquency” to gain more votes; Jean-Luc Mélenchon (candidate of the far-left La France Insoumise) fashions himself as a champion of an anti-system revolution, hoping to win the votes he lacked at the last presidential election to reach the runoff.As the entire political spectrum tears itself apart using the events of October 17th, as the public stands in horror before the ravages committed by the looters, the claims of the high schoolers who started the movement in September are slowly forgotten. At the beginning, garnering support for the high schoolers was easy: the French education system is collapsing, and students in less-privileged high schools find themselves with crumbling infrastructure, too few teachers, and a career and higher-education service that lacks the transparency and efficiency to give them any sense of hope. While France once prided itself on the exceptional quality of its education system, it has now recorded the lowest PISA scores (the OECD’s assessment of 15-year-old students’ academic skills across 91 countries) in its history, despite French high schoolers having about 320 more hours of annual instruction than the average of EU countries with available data. On top of that, and even more importantly, the country’s national public health agency published a survey in 2024 (conducted in 2022) in which 24% of high schoolers reported suicidal thoughts over the previous 12 months, rising to 31% among girls. In short, French high schoolers face a failing education in an environment that fosters hopelessness rather than equality of opportunity. The legitimacy of the movement makes its overshadowing by the violence of others all the more maddening. Because make no mistake: the violence perpetrated on October 17 by rioters, many of whom had nothing to do with the high schoolers, and the political exploitation that followed, will inevitably bury the students’ movement.We have now entered an aftermath where polarisation has reached such heights that any form of dialogue seems forsaken. Condemning the looters’ violence makes you a traitor to one side of the country; defending the claims of the high schoolers (and other protesters) makes you a traitor to the other. It is as if we had all become incapable of accepting that two truths can coexist without cancelling each other out. Denouncing the violence France witnessed should not stop us from recognising the legitimacy of the students’ claims that laid the foundation of this movement. Decrying police abuses against civilians, sometimes children, should not rule out our ability to oppose the pillaging by those whose only conviction is chaos. The despair of the country’s high schoolers should command humility and a willingness to build consensus, not the eternal infighting the political extremes offer us.Watching this weekend unfold, the distress of the population, the impotence of the government, and the sheer violence shown by all sides, it is hard not to believe the system is suffocating. Like a wounded beast, it crawls bleeding on the ground, knowing it is not going anywhere. In such times, turning to history is one way to keep hope. For, contrary to what some commentators would have us believe, social change is possible in, and only in, a democracy. It was the case in October 1983: following a summer of police violence and racist attacks, a small group of young people set out from Marseille on the March for Equality and Against Racism. Their non-violent march drew growing support along the way, and tens of thousands greeted them in Paris, where President Mitterrand received a delegation and announced the ten-year residence card, which the group was calling for. Let this be a reminder that the peacefulness of a movement can sometimes be what ensures its success, even if violence sometimes appears to be the only way to be heard. But for that to be true, political exploitation of the cause must stop, and the government must show its willingness to listen. If it fails to do so, it cannot act surprised when fire starts catching.

Ethan recounts his experience at a parisian protest and analyses how public figures are delegitimising the cause.

Share:

Share on facebook
Facebook
Share on twitter
Twitter
Share on pinterest
Pinterest
Share on linkedin
LinkedIn

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

On Key

Related Posts

Robot Combat is a Sport

Emerson makes his case as to why robot fighting shares enough similarity so more traditional sports.

scroll to top