Written by Willow Imam
Illustration by Anonymous
Do you view the main parties as untrustworthy? Are you dissatisfied with politics? Do you think your vote doesn’t matter? The next time an election rolls around, you should try ‘Staying Home’.
‘Staying Home’ has dominated elections since the dawn of timetheir conception, only ever leaving a UK Ggeneral Eelection without the preference of more than 20% of the electorate twice and winning a plurality in every election since 2000 except one.
But, never has it been more popular than now: in 2024, 40.2% of voters chose ‘Staying Home’ over any other party – almost double the share of the electorate that voted for Labour.
This would be impressive enough if If we didn’t live under First Past Tthe Post, where a party’s vote share doesn’t necessarily indicate the number of seats they get,: when accounting for this, ‘Staying Home’ would have won an unbelievable 94% of seats – 611 out of the 650 in the House of Commons, pushing Labour to third with only 13 seats.
But why does this matter?
When voters choose ‘Staying Home’, political Political parties are incentivised to create policies to pander to those who are more likely to vote, advantaging them. Additionally, When voters choose ‘Staying Home,’ it means that representatives cannotmay not represent the interests and values of a majority, let alone or even just a significant proportion of their constituents – in Manchester Rusholme, only 40% of people voted so only 40% of the constituency has had their values considered at all in the selection of their representativetheir values have been considered in choosing their representative.
What makes ‘Staying Home’ so attractive?
It would be easy to claim that the issue is political disengagement, that the public has simply checked out of politics. However, this isn’t the case – alternative forms of participation are still going strong, arguably stronger than ever: in the 21st century2000s alone, after voter turnout dropped by more than 10%, we’ve seen hundreds of thousands still marched against the War in Iraq, for a second EU referendum, in support of Palestine, in opposition to the far-right, and many more causes.
The evolution of the UK class system makes part of the problem inevitable. Part of the problem is inevitable, as a product of wider socio-economic changes. In the past, there was a social pressure to vote: certain classes were tied to certain political parties – the working-class to the Labour Party and the upper-class to the Conservative Party. But, as a result of class de-alignment (the decline of the traditional manual working-class, the rise of the salaried middle-class and increasing intergenerational and intragenerational social mobility), the ties between these groups and their parties has weakened, and with them, the pressures to vote.
However, there are other, more actionable problems: There is a complete lack of trust in formal politics and a disbelief that any one’s vote matters., to name two.
On one hand, people People do not trust their politicians, nor do they trust the institution of politics more generally – 45% of people say they ‘almost never’ trust governments of any party to place the needs of the nation above the interests of their own political party and 58% say they ‘almost never’ trust ‘politicians of any party in Britain to tell the truth when they are in a tight corner’. The reasons for this distrust are grounded in a lack of connection between constituents and their local MPs, a much greater focus by news media on national politics, and dubious behaviour by politicians that in no way displays or encourages respect for the institution of Parliament.
On the other hand, Furthermore, people have no reason to believe their vote will do anything. This is, in part, an inevitable product of calculus: with a population of millions, how can the vote of one person ever truly matter?
However, it’s in no way assisted by our electoral system that sees the vast majority of votes wasted or ineffective, with 22 million votes in 2024 (75%) making no difference to the final outcome- 75%. This means that millions of voters at each election go unrepresented, such as the 4 million Reform voters in 2024 that only managed to garner 5 seats between them, giving them lessno motivation to vote in future.
The evolution of the UK class system makes part of the problem inevitable. In the past, there was a social pressure to vote: certain classes were tied to certain political parties – the working-class to the Labour Party and the upper-class to the Conservative Party. But, as a result of class de-alignment (the decline of the traditional manual working-class, the rise of the salaried middle-class and increasing intergenerational and intragenerational social mobility), the ties between these groups and their parties has weakened, and with them, the pressures to vote.
What can be done?
Recommendations to combat people choosing ‘Staying Home’ often centre on the practice of voting itself: compulsory voting, e-voting, postal voting. However, although a government with a mandate from only 20% of its people is a problem in its own right, these policies don’t tackle the real problems discussed in this article that push people not to vote in the first place. Voting is a litmus test for attitudes of political trust and agency, and dying it blue isn’t going to change the result of the test.
One necessary change needs to be in the culture of politics. When politicians engage in scandal, tribalism, and generally inappropriate behaviour in and outside of Parliament, such as getting into physical altercations in the Chamber, it doesn’t breed faith in democracy or encourage civil pride.
Additionally, there needs to be more focus by news outlets on the activities of backbench MPs – backbench MPs engage in debates on politics, bipartisan committee work to scrutinize policy (such as the wait for disability benefits or the UK’s military capabilities), and organise and participate in campaigns for their constituents. By ignoring them, we foster an obsession with national level politics that alienates individuals and disincentives them from voting.
Finally, a fundamental change would need to be to the electoral system. First Past the Post not only creates unrepresentative governments and ‘safe seats’ (where one party is almost guaranteed to win, reducing incentives to vote alternatively), a problem in its own right, but it renders the vast majority of voters meaningless, hugely discouraging the act the next time an election rolls around. It also produces ‘safe seats’ where one party is almost guaranteed to win so, if you’re a member of another party, there’s near-to-no reason to vote. It would also help change the political culture as the electoral system plays a large role in producing the adversarial and unrespectable nature of our politics.
Ultimately, if the democratic system ever hopes to weaken the vice grip that ‘Staying Home’ has on our democracy, something has to be done., oOtherwise, it seems political distrust will continue to have more of a mandate than any other policy in British politics.
